I saw something on social media recently, the source of which I’m now forgetting, that suggested ending the day with a short list of what’s not wrong.
I sort of laughed when I first read it—as far as evaluation goes, “not wrong” seemed like setting the bar low.
The more I thought about it, though, the more I liked it.
Listen, I love the idea of gratitude journaling and gratitude lists. And I’ve tried many times to create a habit of making them at night.
But the thing about gratitude is that it’s one of those sensations, like joy, forgiveness, or desire, that’s hard to grow on barren land. You can place more focus on what’s already there, but you can’t manufacture what’s not.
There are days—bad days, tough days, depressed days, angry days, whatever—when authentic gratitude feels inaccessible.
I can always dutifully list off the things that I know I’m fortunate to have. But this is intellectual awareness, whereas gratitude is a feeling. There are days when I’m too darn sad or mad or overwhelmed to tap into that feeling.
On those days, thinking about what’s not wrong seems like a more honest and achievable aim than a gratitude list.
This reminds me a little of the notion of body neutrality as a goal of eating disorder treatment.
Many folks in eating disorder recovery initially express the goal of loving their bodies. But body love can be a tall order for someone who’s in recovery.
Neutrality—being in a state of respecting and accepting one’s body, without feeling the need to love it or approve of it enthusiastically—is gentler.
I think it’s also a healthy goal in the sense that recovery is about learning to not place excessive attention and focus on body shape in the first place, to create an inner peace and sense of self-worth that can withstand bad body days.
Not sure if that comparison makes sense. But anyway, I’ve found that neutral and passive emotions can be more accessible than positive or active ones during difficult times.
On any given night this past week, it would have been very hard for me to end the day with a list of things that I was feeling actively grateful for.
But I could take note of what wasn’t wrong.
Acknowledging the things that weren’t wrong, the things that were OK, helped me to avoid excessive negativity while also honoring my internal state.
I think that’s what I really needed, in the end: permission to say that many things weren’t wrong and some really were.
When I was unsuccessfully trying to Google the original place where I saw this advice, I stumbled on this article by Arthur C. Brooks, about making a “to-don’t” list in order to identify what’s valuable.
A to-don’t isn’t the same as what I’m writing about today. But it feels connected, and it’s an intriguing counterpoint to the pressures of to-do lists.
If active gratitude is within your reach this week, then that’s wonderful. Life always feels especially meaningful to me when gratitude is flowing.
If things are hard, and you can’t seem to muster up the gratitude that you want to feel, or know that you could feel, if only your mood and outlook were different, then maybe you can simply notice what isn’t wrong.
What’s not broken, not hurting, not difficult?
I hope that you notice plenty of little, un-wrong, things.
Happy Sunday, friends. Till soon.
xo
On Friday, I was honored to be a part of a conversation titled “Hot Topics in Eating Disorder Treatment,” hosted by Castlewood Treatment Centers and Balanced Eating Disorder Treatment Center here in New York City. The workshop’s moderators were Tammy Beasley and Melainie Rogers, both registered dietitians who specialize in ED treatment. One of the topics under discussion was whether or not vegans can and should be treated in high-level, in-patient care. Tammy and Melainie invited me to share about my own recovery…
“Young at Heart” is a ballad that most of us have heard at least a few times; it’s ubiquitous enough to appear in movies pretty often. It happens to have been one of my grandmother’s favorite songs, and the tune she always put me to sleep with when I stayed with her. I don’t know whether she picked this song as my lullaby because she loved Frank Sinatra, or because she thought I’d like it, or simply because it was on her mind…
In the past couple weeks, I’ve gotten lots of messages from people who also came down with Covid over the winter holidays. Many people were in the same boat as me—quarantining unexpectedly, instead of seeing family and friends as planned—and it was really nice to have some camaraderie and support. I’ve also been struck by some of the feelings that dealing with Covid has evoked. For example, I was surprised by the number of messages I got expressing shame or feelings of failure…
Hello, friends. Happy Sunday, and thanks for all of the enthusiasm for Richa’s book on Friday! Keep those giveaway entries coming. Steven and I are winding up a few weekends of day trips and overnights with family, and I’m in the midst of two big work projects and my first RD class (Food Safety and Management–not the most scintillating, but at least it’s going quickly). All in all, it feels as though June is flying by, and I’m hoping that I’ll have a…
Leave a Comment
Hello Gena,
This is a wonderful post. I have often thought the same thing about gratitude journals. When I am feeling very low, I find that trying to list things I am grateful for makes me feel worse rather than better, because I know in my heart that (1) I’m only making the list as a response to not feeling okay, and that (2) when I feel okay, I don’t need to make the list in the first place.
I’ve learned over the years that a lot of the hacks and truisms we are told about how to take care of our mental health don’t actually work for me, and I have to find my own solution.
I’m glad you’re finding your own solutions, too. Maybe that’s the most important part of looking after our mental health?
R xo
I want to live a good life and eating right is part of it. You present ideas thst make eating right irresistible. I have been distracted of late, but I am tuning back in. Thanks!
Thank you for sharing these thoughts, Gena. I love the idea of a list of what’s not wrong. I’m going to try it. Wishing you gentleness and ease in the coming week.
Yes! This reminds me of a guided meditation I tried recently, to cope with some overwhelming-feeling physical pain. The premise was to do an inventory of your body and find a part of it that was not in pain, and then spend time actively noticing that it is not in pain. Ideally, one can find quite a few such places, even when a lot of things do, in fact, hurt. But even if it’s just one or two, it’s a valuable wedge against the relentless voice in your head asserting that EVERYTHING hurts. I like the idea of using this in a broader context!