Raw witches fingers decorated 1

So glad you all like the chocolate maca milk! I can’t wait to get back to my blender so that I can whip up another batch.

As I mentioned in yesterday’s post, I had a chance to make a couple of Halloween-themed treats last week before I left for New York. For someone who’s basically a subpar crafter and decorator, I was pretty proud of the spooky finger cookies you see above! They were super fun to make, and even more fun to eat. And I’m now I’m here to show you how you can make them at home, too.

Raw witches fingers decorated 4

I got the idea for these cookies from Chloe and Kim, who have each created fantastic baked vegan versions of this popular Halloween treat. I wanted to create a version using nuts, seeds, and dates — the standard base from which I create all of my cookies, snack bars, pie crusts, and crumbles.

As I was rustling around to see what sort of nuts were handy, I discovered a bag of sesame seeds, and realized that sesame is a highly underutilized ingredient in my kitchen. I love the taste (tahini is one of my favorite things in the universe), but for whatever reason I shy away from using sesame seeds, except when I’m making homemade gomasio. This was a perfect opportunity to put sesame flavor to use in a sweet recipe.

Raw, Vegan Witches’ Finger Cookies

  • 1 cup strawberries or raspberries
  • 3 tablespoons chia seeds
  • 1 cup sesame seeds
  • ½ cup raw cashews
  • Generous pinch sea salt
  • 1 heaping cup tightly packed, pitted medjool dates
  • About 20 blanched, whole almonds
  1. 1. Blend the berries and chia in a blender till smooth. Transfer to a mason jar or glass and allow it to thicken into a "jam"--ideally, you want to let it sit overnight, but a few hours will work. Add an extra tablespoon of chia if it's too thin.
  2. 2. Add the sesame seeds, cashews, and salt to a food processor fitted with the S blade. Grind for about 15 seconds, or until they're broken down. Add the dates and continue processing until the mixture resembles a crumbly, sticky (but not too moist) raw "dough" (similar to what you'd aim for if you were making homemade Larabars!).
  3. 3. Take a small handful (maybe 3 tablespoons) of the dough and roll it into a strip that's about as long and wide as a finger. Shape it to form knuckles and a fingertip.
  4. 4. Use your finger to make an indentation at the tip.
  5. 5. Add a small amount of the jam to the indentation. Press a blanched almond on top to create the fingernail! Serve.
  6. Makes about 16-20 cookies. Stored in the fridge, these will last about a week.

Witches fingers how to

Note that this recipe can be even simpler if you use a store-bought jam of your choice (or homemade jam that you’ve stored). I keep the extra strawberry chia mixture to spread on Ezekiel toast with some coconut butter (yum!), but no need to make it if you’d like to streamline the process.

Raw witches fingers decorated 2

I’d imagine that this is a really fun recipe to make with kids. But if you’re a big kid like me, don’t hesitate to make it and keep it all to yourself (well, actually, I shared my batch with Valerie, who initially looked a little confused/grossed out but was ultimately won over by the sesame flavor). If you don’t have sesame seeds, it’s no big deal. You can use all cashews (1 1/2 cups total), walnuts, or almonds. This should be a very flexible, forgiving recipe. I hope you enjoy it.


Tagged with →