I woke up yesterday with a little more lightness in my heart than had been there earlier this week. And when I’m feeling lighthearted, my first instinct is to bake.
There are so many things I might have posted on this Easter Sunday. Hot cross buns, which I’ve been wanting to make (and make well—my last batch was a total fail) for a while. Pie. A brunch dish, like French toast. Chocolate eggs. Any number of different cakes.
But all I’ve been able to think about is carrot cake. Maybe not surprising, since carrot cake is my favorite cake. And since cake is my favorite dessert, that puts carrot cake at the top of my treats hierarchy.
This isn’t my first carrot cake recipe. A couple years back, I posted a vegan pumpkin carrot cake that’s a hybrid of pumpkin bread and carrot cake, and therefore perfect for fall. Because pumpkin bread is half of its inspiration, that cake is hearty and dense. The carrot and raisins are predominant, so the interior of the cake is heavily textured, more heft and substance than lightness.
It’s exactly how that particular cake should be. And that’s how a lot of carrot cakes are: very dense, studded with dried fruits and nuts, unmistakably carrot-y. I love that kind of carrot cake, which is the type of carrot cake I’ve most often found in vegan bakeries here in NYC. Lately, though, I’ve been craving a carrot cake recipe that’s a little more traditionally cake-like: light and airy. I want this cake to be carrot cake, for sure—carrots, raisins, and walnuts included—but I want it to be a little fluffier than usual.
You can imagine how excited I was when I saw that Coral Lee had posted a carrot cake on Food52 that features a genius trick: grating the carrots on a microplane, rather than shredding them. So smart. In Coral’s words, “fine-grating with a microplane yields carrot shreds—even wisps!—that better meld with the batter, and make for a more ubiquitous carrot flavor, without the salad-y texture.”
I had a laugh when I read “salad-y,” because that’s how so many of my carrot cakes and muffins have been.
This carrot cake, which is inspired by Coral’s recipe, is my new favorite cake. I say that semi-regularly about new cakes, so take it with a grain of salt, but I think it’ll at least be true of carrot cake. It’s my dream carrot cake: as hearty and spiced and orange as it should be, but tender and light enough on the inside to meet my cake lover’s expectations of a nice crumb. And, true to classic carrot cake form, it features a whipped and creamy, yet rich cream cheese frosting.
You could get fancy with the decoration here. Chopped nuts, frosting carrots, flowers: they’d all look pretty. But part of what I love so much about carrot cake is its slightly rustic, homey feel. This may be a classy carrot cake, but it’s still carrot cake. I frosted the cake and was happy enough with its swirled exterior to call it a day.
In her recipe, Coral offers nuts and raisins as being optional, in keeping with the aim of a cake that hints at elegance and austerity. I added them, but I stuck to her quantities of a half cup of each and the guidance to chop the nuts finely. I was so glad I did this, and it’s how I’ll make carrot cake from now on. The nuts and raisins are there, but they don’t weigh the cake down.
I have a microplane grater, but I suspected it might be slightly faster to use the fine shred setting on my box grater. It worked perfectly; you can see the wisps Coral mentions below:
If you’d rather use a microplane grater, that’s fine. If you have a box grater with a fine setting, good. And if you only have a regular grater, don’t worry! Your carrot cake will taste delicious, only it’ll have the more traditional texture.
This Easter isn’t really my holiday; my mom and I didn’t make a big deal of it when I was growing up, as she’s Greek Orthodox. Today I celebrate Greek Easter with her and Passover with some of my chosen family.
Still, I do attach meaning to Easter Sunday. I greet it as a celebration of rebirth, new beginnings, and hope. The promise of life everlasting in the sense that new things are always starting as old ones pass away. I welcome it as a sign of springtime and shifting seasons.
Today, in spite of the darkness and loss that surrounds me here in New York City, I’m finding a tiny way to celebrate. It’s cake, and cake may not seem like the most profound way to celebrate anything.
But for me, food is always profound in that it’s my way of expressing the desire to live, and this is especially true of baking. I love cooking, but it’s a matter of necessity as much as pleasure: I can’t survive without food. There’s no particular need for cake (or pie, or vegan croissants). My baking is an expression of playfulness, joy, and recognizing the sweetness of life. That sweetness is hard to find sometimes, but it’s there, and a slice of cake can bring it to life.
I’m excited for my next slice of this new favorite. And I hope that some of you might celebrate with it at some point, too. Happy Easter Sunday, if you’re observing it, and I’ll be back in a couple days with another recipe.
xo
This post may contain affiliate links. If you use these links to buy something I may earn a commission. Visit my privacy policy to learn more.
Leave a Comment
Testing form from FD
Hi (:
This looks delicious.
I was wondering about the amount of confectioners sugar. 4 cups is a little excessive for me personally, but I’d love to make this cake. By how much do you think I can cut it that amount down, and still maintain the overall flavor/texture of the cake?
Hey Joe! I wouldn’t go less than 3 cups, personally. The icing will taste good, it’ll just be very rich and not as whipped/fluffy as the stated amount. You could try adding 2 cups, seeing what the texture is like, and then adding as much more as you need to get the consistency that works while being less than the amount called for.
This cake is amazing! I am not much of a baker but wanted to make a vegan cake for my daughter’s first Birthday at the end of September (she is allergic to milk and eggs). My frosting skills need a lot of work (I really underestimated how difficult that is to do), but I cannot believe how well this turned out. Thank you so much!
Hooray! I’m so glad to hear that, Deanna.
I want to make your carrot cake, can I substitute flaxseed with anything? Do I need it at all? What does it do? Tks
Hi Ruth! It functions to replace egg, but I think you’ll still have good texture if you omit it. You can just add 3 T water to the wet ingredients, minus the flax. Hope you enjoy!
Do you mind sharing which brand of cream cheese you used for the frosting? It looks so fluffy and delicious! Thank you!
Absolutely! I used Kite Hill 🙂
thank you for sharing that eating healthy can also taste good this gives the public a different perspective on nutrition
I made this and it was surprisingly easy and delicious. I made it with whole wheat flour and I’m sure it’s a little more dense than regular flour but just a delicious! Really loving this recipe!!
So glad you liked it Leanna!
As always, this recipe is something I really want to try! Thanks for sharing!!!
Hope you’ll enjoy it!
Hello!!!
I’m look forward to making this cake on the weekend. Do you think I can substitute the applesauce with pineapples? Thanks!
annalisa
ps. thank you for sharing so may great recipes.
You’re welcome! I think you could do that substitution if you puree them. Good luck 🙂
Do you have any guidance on making this gluten free? Would almond flour work? Or a combination of almond and coconut flour? Something else?
Hi ReaderRita! It can be made gluten free with a mix of GF grain flours and starches. I’d recommend using a 1:1 GF all purpose flour; I like the King Arthur Measure for Measure flour a lot! I wouldn’t recommend almond or coconut flour.